Paper vs. Vanilla vs. Spigot: Which Minecraft Server Software Is Right for You?
Three server software options, one question
You want to set up a Minecraft server and you are facing the first big decision: which server software should it be? Vanilla, Spigot, or Paper — all three of them run Minecraft, but the differences under the hood are huge.
This comparison helps you make the right choice. Spoiler: for most players there is a clear recommendation.
What is what?
Vanilla
Vanilla is the original server software from Mojang. You download it directly from minecraft.net and start it. No modifications, no plugins, no extras. What Mojang ships is what you get — nothing more, nothing less.
Spigot
Spigot is a fork of CraftBukkit, the original plugin platform for Minecraft. Spigot adopted the Bukkit API and extended it, built in performance improvements, and has been the standard for plugin servers for years. Most Minecraft plugins are developed for the Spigot/Bukkit API.
Paper
Paper is a fork of Spigot — a fork of a fork. That sounds like a Russian nesting doll, but it brings massive benefits. Paper has grown into the most widely used Minecraft server software in the world, and for good reason: it takes Spigot, optimizes performance drastically, and adds its own features that make life easier for both players and server admins.
The big comparison
Performance
This is where the biggest difference shows. Vanilla servers struggle with the tick rate from 10+ players onward, especially when many chunks are loaded. Spigot improves this noticeably, but Paper goes one big step further.
Paper's most important performance features:
- Asynchronous chunk loading — chunks are loaded in separate threads, keeping the main thread free
- Optimized entity processing — less lag from mobs and items
- Reduced redstone calculations — smarter handling of redstone updates
- Lower RAM usage — same number of players, less memory required
In practice, this means: a Paper server with 2 GB of RAM runs smoothly for 2-5 players, while a vanilla server can start stuttering with the same number of players. At 10+ players the difference becomes even more pronounced.
Plugin compatibility
Vanilla does not support plugins. Period. You can use datapacks, but that is it.
Spigot is the foundation of the entire Bukkit/Spigot plugin ecosystem. Thousands of plugins are available, from simple teleport commands to complete minigame frameworks.
Paper is fully compatible with Bukkit and Spigot plugins and additionally offers its own Paper API with extended capabilities. If a plugin works on Spigot, it works on Paper too. The other way around, there are plugins that were developed specifically for the Paper API and do not run on plain Spigot.
Built-in features
Paper ships with features for which you would have to install extra plugins on vanilla or Spigot:
- Anti-Xray — prevents X-ray cheating directly at the server level, without needing a separate plugin
- Improved book and chat validation — protects against exploits that are possible on vanilla servers
- Configurable mob spawning rules — finer control over mob behavior without plugins
- Per-world configuration — different settings per world are possible
Redstone behavior
One point that keeps being debated: Paper slightly changes redstone behavior compared to vanilla. Certain redstone machines that rely on vanilla bugs or undocumented behavior may not work identically on Paper. For most players this is irrelevant, but if you are planning elaborate technical redstone builds, you should know about it. Many of these changes can also be disabled via the Paper config.
Updates and community
Vanilla receives updates directly from Mojang.
Spigot usually delivers updates within a few days of a Minecraft update.
Paper is often even faster than Spigot and regularly ships its own patches for bugs and security vulnerabilities that are still open in vanilla or Spigot. The Paper community is active, the documentation is good, and you get help quickly on Discord.
Which software should you choose?
Choose vanilla if...
- you want the pure, unmodified Minecraft experience
- you only play with 2-4 friends and do not need plugins
- you want to build technical redstone builds 1:1 like in singleplayer
- maximum compatibility with new snapshots matters to you
Choose Spigot if...
- you want to use plugins but may depend on specific Spigot-only configurations
- vanilla is too slow for you, but you want to stay as close to the original as possible
Honestly, there are few reasons today to choose Spigot instead of Paper. Paper can do everything Spigot can, and more.
Choose Paper if...
- you want the best performance
- you want to use plugins (or possibly will in the future)
- you will have more than 5 players on the server
- you want built-in exploit protection and Anti-Xray
- you simply want the safest and most stable option
For most servers, Paper is the right choice. It is faster, safer, and more flexible than the alternatives, without you having to make any compromises.
What resources does a Paper server need?
Paper is frugal. For a small server with 2-5 players, 2 GB of RAM is enough. From 5-10 players, 4 GB makes sense, and for larger servers with many plugins and worlds you should plan 8 GB.
Because Paper is so resource-efficient, it is a great fit for hosting models where you only pay for what you use. At WZH Cloud, for example, you start with a Cloud S package and scale up as your server grows — without contract lock-in or fixed monthly packages.
Conclusion
Vanilla is for purists, Spigot is the veteran, and Paper is the current standard. If you are starting a Minecraft server today and are not deliberately avoiding plugins, go with Paper. You get better performance, more security, and full plugin compatibility in a single package. Your server and your players will thank you.